विनाअनुदानीत खाजगी कॉलेज आणि आरक्षण

मिसळपाववरील एका चर्चेतून पडलेले काही प्रश्न

सरकारी विद्यापीठाशी सलग्न, खाजगी, नॉनमायनॉरीटी कॉलेजमधील ८०% जागा सरकारी नियमानेच भरणे सक्तीचे आहे की संस्थाचालकांनी ऐच्छीक संमती दिल्यानेच हे होतंय?

उदा
www.timesofindia.com/city/allahabad/No-reservation-in-pvt-unaided-self-f... ही बातमी पहा.

a. त्यातील private unaided and self- finance educational institutes म्हणजे काय?
b. Deen Dayal Upadhaya Gorakhpur University हे उत्तरप्रदेशातलं सरकारी विद्यापीठच आहे ना?

तसेच
http://www.thehindu.com/2005/08/13/stories/2005081307770100.htm या बातमीमधुन सर्वोच्च न्यायालयाचा निकाल:

* Unaided minority and non-minority institutions have absolute rights to establish, administer and admit students of their choice
* These institutions can have their own admission procedures'

ही अजूनेक लिंक:
http://prayatna.typepad.com/education/2005/08/summary_of_the_.html

Reservation policy:

Neither the policy of reservation can be enforced by the State nor any quota or percentage of admissions can be carved out to be appropriated by the State in a minority or non-minority unaided
educational institution.

Minority institutions are free to admit students of their own choice including students of non-minority community as also members of their own community from other States, both to a limited extent only and not in a manner and to such an extent that their minority educational
institution status is lost.

So far as appropriation of quota by the State and enforcement of its reservation policy is concerned, we do not see much of difference between non-minority and minority unaided educational institutions.

The State cannot insist on private educational
institutions which receive no aid from the State to implement State's policy on reservation for granting admission on lesser percentage of marks, i.e. on any criterion except merit .

Merely because the resources of the State in providing professional education are limited, private educational institutions, which intend to provide better professional education, cannot be forced by the State to make admissions available on the basis of reservation policy to less meritorious
candidate.

Unaided institutions, as they are not deriving any aid from State funds, can have their own admissions if fair, transparent, non- exploitative and
based on merit.

यासगळ्यातून मला असा अर्थ लागतोय की 'सिंहगड कॉलेज किंवा भारती
विद्यापीठ यांना जरी सरकारकडून मान्यता असली, सरकारी विद्यापीठांशी सलग्न
असले तरीही ते वॉलंटरी कंसेंटनेच ८०% जागा भरतायत; सक्तीने नाही.'

हे आकलन बरोबर आहे की चूक?